The Bloody Struggle in the Hexagon
February 8, 2010 |
Mr. Blackburn
Handsome Joe Lunardi disclosed, via his Twitter account, that he will more than likely have six A-10 teams when his bracket projection comes out later today. This is a direct result of the PAC-10’s continual abortion of a season and the A-10 splitting into two distinct factions, a suitable six and whatever else lies at the bottom of the Atlantic Ten barrel. Conceivably, the A-10 is going to finish with several teams in the 12-4/11-5 range, so the latter half of the league schedule will clearly determine who will play their way into, and out of, a bid.
At this stage of the season two things should be crystal clear: first, you cannot afford to lose to a team outside of the top six of the league. Out of the current top six, only Dayton (@ St. Joe’s) and Richmond (@ Saint Louis) have lost to bottom feeders. A loss to the bottom half of the league could serve as a nail in the coffin from here on out, as the top six of the league takes turns beating each other up. Second, the chances of the league receiving six (even five) bids are spurious at best. So many variables would have to fall into place for that scenario to occur that it’s not even worth talking about at this point. Considering this website once spent a week discussing women’s leggings that is saying a mouthful.
If we are operating under the assumption that the league is presently worthy of six bids, and for our purposes here, we are, it may be beneficial (just nod yes) to take a peek at what lies ahead for the league’s hexagon of power. Who has the easiest road ahead? Which team faces an uphill battle? It’s quite possible that a week or two from now one of these teams will have played its way out of the discussion. The schedules may provide a clue, or at the very least allow us to pretend that the picture is somewhat clearer.

Teams are presented in order of scheduling ease. The analysis gives each team an overtly favorable benefit of doubt.
1)
Dunphy is sitting prettyTemple: The Owls appear to have the easiest slate of games left on the docket. With only two games against teams in the hexagon (Dayton and Rhode Island), both at home, Temple would realistically only need to split them to have the inside track on first place. After this weekend’s game against Rhode Island, Dunphy’s squad has a pair of very winnable games against St. Bonaventure and St. Joseph’s before UD comes calling later this month. After the Dayton tilt, Temple’s closes the season out with three games against squads that are currently a combined 10-16 in the league. Lastly, Temple does not have to deal with the pressure of playing crucial games back-to-back; they have an advantageously arranged path ahead of them.
2) Xavier: After traveling to Gainesville for an out-of-conference clash with the Florida Gators (which I’m not quite sure will have a major effect on the Muskies’ hopes win or lose), Xavier returns to take on St. Joseph’s. A win against the Hawks puts the Musketeers at nine wins on the season. Even if X only wins one game out of their next three (@Charlotte, @Saint Louis and vs. Richmond), they would have registered ten wins with just two conference games remaining. Those two opponents? The resigned Rams of Fordham and the dormant Bonnies of Saint Bonaventure. Sweep those two teams under the rug and Xavier reaches 12 wins without breaking a sweat. X fans are right to be satisfied with their remaining table. Only two games in the hexagon and a pair of gimmies to close out the campaign. That’s fairly smooth sailing for our overlords.
3) Rhode Island: If Rhody can take out Richmond this week, their path to an at-large bid seems like it could be all but locked up. On the other hand, if the Rams lose two games this week – very possible considering they face Richmond and Temple – they will get booted from the hexagon (which I guess becomes a pentagon?). If the Rams can go 1-1, a trio of very winnable games awaits them (@Saint Louis, Fordham and @St. Bonaventure). Under this scenario, Rhody would have 11 wins going into games against Charlotte and UMass. Another split at the end of the season brings their win total to a beatific 12. So, Rhody’s formula for success looks something like this: split-three-split. Not exactly catchy, but neither was Bob Dylan and he uses a diamond fork to eat his tabouleh.
4)
Dan and Luke need you to believe in themDayton: The Flyers were able to stave off their execution with an impressive win over Xavier this weekend, maybe you heard about it. Out of all six teams, Dayton has the most ground to make up as they are currently 1.5 games out of fifth place. UD is the outlier in the hexagon, as they cannot afford a single slip-up outside the top six. A loss to Saint Louis, Duquesne or La Salle could signal their dismissal from the conference elite (by the way, elite is in no way an operative word in this case). As previously stated, only Dayton and Richmond have losses outside the top six, and the Spiders are unlikely to lose another game outside the hexagon.
A huge opportunity awaits the Flyers this Wednesday, as Charlotte comes to town (the 10th is going to be a busy day in the six-sided circle, as UD faces off against the Niners, and Richmond grapples with Rhode Island). A loss wouldn’t necessarily be catastrophic, given the opponent, but a 5-4 record on its face does not inspire confidence for the future. Even with a loss this Wednesday, UD has a three-pack of games that are winnable by reasonable standards: @Saint Louis, La Salle and @Duquesne. A clean sweep, however improbable, would place the Flyers at 8-4 with four games to go. Unfortunately, the Flyers have a tough close to the season, including two hexagonal contests on the road (Temple & Richmond). Winning 3-of-4 could be enough to keep the Flyers in the tournament conversation, as UD would have an 11-5 conference record with decent indicators (RPI, SOS, etc.).
Although I wouldn’t feel as comfortable labeling the Charlotte game a “must-win” as I was with Xavier, a loss to the 49ers would certainly inch UD closer to the edge of the ledge. As senseless as it may sound, 6-3 is a world away from 5-4. Even the most hopeful among us would have a hard time believing Dayton could pick itself up after a loss on Wednesday and run close to perfect over the last seven conference games.
5) Charlotte: The Niners have their work cut out for them, as half of their remaining games take place in the homoerotic frenzy of the hexagon. Nevertheless, the 49ers have put themselves in a very enviable position. At 8-1, Charlotte has the most room for error. Discounting games against the top six, Jim Utter’s team faces squads that have a combined record of 8-19. Assuming Shamari Spears and Co. take care of business against its lesser foes, Charlotte would only need to win one-of- four against the top six to end up with 12 wins in the league. Splitting the four games in the hexagon would likely mean a 13-3 mark for Charlotte. So even though Bobby Lutz’s club faces one of the toughest roads from here on out, they are probably sitting the prettiest at this point. A win against Dayton all but sews up an at-large bid for Charlotte.
6) Richmond: As much as it pains me to say it, Richie appears to have the rockiest road ahead. The Spiders face four games in the ring, three of which are on the road. Outside of Dayton, no team can afford a loss to a bottom-feeder less than the Spiders. Wednesday’s tilt with Rhode Island will either provide Richmond with some breathing room or paint them into a corner. A victory over the Rams could see Richmond roll off four straight victories in route to an 11-2 record (after URI, Richmond faces the Bonnies, Fordham and GW). Richie’s schedule is difficult simply because of the way it is laid out. If they do not care take of business over the next two weeks, they face a murder’s row to close out the season. The prospect of taking two out of three from Xavier, Dayton and Charlotte is a daunting task for any club in the league – even more so when a potential bid is on the line.
CNNSI's Andy Glockner has a decent article about the state of the conference here. A quick excerpt:
The other aspect of the brewing perfect bid storm is that the league standings are starting to shake out in inverse order of quality of nonleague performance. Richmond, with three quality wins, has more wiggle room than teams like Xavier, which suffered a series of very tough nonleague losses, and Charlotte, which pounded undermanned Louisville at Freedom Hall but was blown out in several other games against NCAA tournament-level foes. Therefore, for the league's sake, it's a positive that Xavier leads the way at 8-1, with only a five-point loss at nationally ranked Temple sullying its A-10 campaign. It's good that Charlotte already has won at Richmond and beaten Temple. It's OK, for now, that Richmond lost at struggling Saint Louis and also ate one of the three home league losses so far for the top six squads. If Dayton can hold serve in huge upcoming home games against Xavier and Charlotte, the Flyers also should remain strongly in the mix.
"We have to figure out a way to make up for [the home loss to Rhode Island]," Dayton coach Brian Gregory said. "The good thing for all the teams is you'll have the opportunity to do some things, because if you win, you'll be beating some really good teams. At points in the past, if you got yourself into a hole, if you beat some teams, you may be able to get out of the hole with just wins, but maybe not the perception of what kind of wins those are."





















Reader Comments (20)
Yes Blackburn ... Bring that heat baby!
Hexagon all day.
That is what I am talking about!
/still sitting in the corner for being a horrible horrible person when drunk...
Outstanding post, Blackburn. Although I think you're understanding the importance of Xavier's game at Florida. They can afford a loss, but a loss will put them in an interesting spot and could make the Charlotte road game a must win. How do you judge a team whose best win OOC was an NIT Cincy team, no significant wins away from home, and a 12-4 league record? I don't know.
Dayton has to beat Charlotte. MUST WIN. They can't afford ANY more home losses. They could afford a loss to Duquesne because they have other chances to steal a huge road win, however unlikely. Charlotte is the last significant home game. Can't lose it. Period.
In the end, I think Charlotte may be due for a bit of a market correction. I really think they've played above their heads a bit, and easily could have lost to GW and Fordham. Then again, maybe they're last year's UD team and just escapes every time. But I wouldn't count on it. They lose 3-4 more games this season, even if they beat UD.
PS: I think the Charlotte vs Richie game at the end of the regular season will ultimately decide a bid.
Got to agree Adam. Charlotte will be hunted now with the big boys and I don't see them standing up.
@Blackburn: I think the one thing you need to take into account, is that a 12 win or 11 win in the league doesn't really matter. The selection committee isn't going to draw a line after number 5 (if we are lucky) and say, these are in. All of the conference schedules aren't even balanced. I think we can all agree that Temple is a lock right now. Great OOC and solid during the conference tilt.
Of the hexagon (which is my new favorite erotic term), Xavier, Charlotte, and Rhode Island don't have stellar OOC wins. Xavier's is Cinci at home, Charlotte's is Louisville at UL (which I guess is okay), and Rhode Island's is Okie State (h), Providence (h), and at Boston College---non of which are that impressive (although they did win at UD arena).
@Daddy D: in a normal year, i would totally agree with you. But considering the state we are in, the A-10 is likely to get more bids than they usually would. With that consideration, conference play becomes paramount. I completely agree with you that the OOC is vital, but if the common consensus is that this is a 4-5 bid league, then where each team finishes in the conference matters.
I think Adam is on to something here.
Blackburn if X loses to Florida they have 0 marquee wins OOC (Including a 10 point loss to a below average Marquette team and a 15 point blow out by Kansas State). They literally would be hanging their hat on splitting with Dayton and possibly splitting with Charlotte.
I think you and Donoher put X on a pedestal because of their past accomplishments (some of that is warranted) but if X goes 12-4 in the league and Dayton goes 11-5 there is no way based on the current resumes that UD would not get the nod over X ... and this isn't even adding in the fact UD just took a shit all over their chest and into their mouth.
I think X, Charlotte and Richmond are all in the same category as UD right now. If X loses to Florida (their only game this week), Richmond loses to URI and UD goes 2-0 (meaning Charlotte loses) ... the shake up for at-large contenders literally shifts to UD.
That is how quickly this can turn.
Worst thing that could happen is if everyone goes 1-1 (including Dayton) and X wins ... then it basically solves nothing and they are still a jumbled mess.
@John: that was kinda the whole point of the post. Outside of Temple, the conference is a muddled mess. The next month is a free-for-all. Again, if you agree with the assessment that the A10 is going to get 4-5 bids, how could a 12-4 X team get shut out?
You touch upon something interesting though, and it was something I avoided discussing due to its sheer complexity, what happens if/when the A10 is still a mess come March?
Make no mistake, UD has the least amount of room to breathe. A loss to Charlotte throws the season into a tailspin.
Agree, UD has little room to breath and Charlotte is a must win (which I think they will get).
My point is ... let's say this happens
Temple (13-3)
URI (13-3)
X (12-4)
Charlotte (12-4)
UD (11-5)
Richmond (11-5)
Assuming one of those wins for UD is over Charlotte. Go look at the entire resume ... UD would get a nod over either Charlotte or X if not both.
Personally, I think Charlotte and Richmond will fade back. What A-10 team can boast Two top 40 rpi non-conference wins ... and maybe even one over a ranked team at the end of the year ...
If UD could go 2-0 this week (I think SLU will be an awesome atmosphere. Mardi Gras in St. Lou is second only to New Orleans in this country and it will be a packed house split down the middle with red and blue drunk people) and X, Rich and Char all loose one game ... I feel a lot better.
@John: in the scenario you put forth, i would agree with you. Again, it would mean UD would have to go 7-2 from here on out, that's a tall order.
Charlotte's the type of team that could lose to a few carps (bottom feeders) at the end of the season. I could see them losing to Dayton, beating Xavier, and then losing their last 3 games (@GW, @URI, RICH)
Well since my "fun three weeks" comment expires next Thursday. Looks like we have three more wins to put up in that time.
We will look good after these fun three weeks are over.
One more thing ... I think this "reputation" thing may have some legs in terms of UD too.
Last year the committee gave us a shot being the last at-large team in the dance and we rewarded them by beating West Virginia ... they will remember that.
My point is if all things are equal (or within one game) conference standings wise between Richmond and Charlotte, UD is going to get the nod ... especially because their overall resume is better and because of what happened last year.
X would be more difficult in terms of jumping because of who they are ... but Rich, Char ... I would feel very comfortable.
And another thing that could make this an even more jumbled mess - what if one of the bottom-feeders (i.e. SLU, or even St. Joe's) comes out of the woodwork and takes the auto bid in Atlantic City? That makes the remaining schedule even more paramount than it looks now. If that happens, I would imagine that 2 of the hexagon teams would get left out, and this last month would probably hold even more clout in determining who gets in.
But I do agree with John in that I think both Charlotte and Richie will be the most likely to fall out of the race by the end of the season. Richmond could very easily lose their last 3 games of the season - and if that happens, I can't see them getting a bid unless they win out in AC.
We really shouldn't be putting this much thought into this, UD is just as likely to shit a brick and be NIT bound as go 7-2 the rest of the way. What can't be taken away is our 25 point pounding of x. Now is the time for reflection and celebration since I have a bad feeling we will all be disappointed soon.
First of all its 6-2.
But just for funzies ... Lunardi, CBS and Yahoo all have 6 A-10 teams in their field.
Man, that would be the day!
@John: i was adding a game for first game of A10 tourney, but yes, 6-2 in regular season.
@BRPride: i can assure you that little thought was put into this.
@Blackburn
Was referring to the commenters...I have no expectations from the staff.
This is something I posted on NinerNation.Net commenting on this article and thought it was worth copying here. Good article Blackburn.
"Yes Richmond and us have the most dificult remaining schedules. But something that is not mentioned is that ALL Four of the remaining six have to GO TO ST. LOUIS. That is not an easy place to win. They have only played 3 home conference games so have 5 of 8 at their place to close it out. Richmond has already lost there and I am pretty confident that two of the top will fall there as well.
However, it is not really fair to call them "Bottom Feeders" bc they are 5-3 (same as UD - which still has to play them twice by the way) and 14-8 overall. A loss to St. Louis would hardly look as bad as Fordham or St. Bonnies as implied. I'm just glad we don't have them down the stretch.
St. Louis will be just as important in deciding the "hexagon's" fate as head to head matchups."
@NinerLove: def true, UD has struggled mightily against SLU in the past. I only classify SLU as a "bottom feeder" simply because they are out of the NCAA picture. Everyone here knows how tough it is to go on the road at win at St. Louis.